Skip to main content

Table 1 Characteristics of the articles included in the review

From: Development of a conceptual model for research on cyclical variation of patient reported outcome measurements (PROMs) in patients with chronic conditions: a scoping review

References

Country

Design

Setting

Conditions

PROMs measurement

Frequencya

Data collection periodb

Study qualityc

aan het Rot et al. 2012

Netherlands

Systematic Review

Various settings

Depression

Between 3 and 10

Varied

3

Abdel-Kader et al. 2014

USA

Observational (Longitudinal)

Secondary care

Kidney disease

4

7 d

3

Bellamy et al. 1991

Canada

RCTd

Secondary care

Rheumatoid arthritis

6

9 d

1

Bromberg et al. 2014

USA

Observational (Longitudinal)

Secondary care

Arthritis

3

1 m

3

Claros-Salinas et al. 2010

Germany

Observational (Longitudinal)

Secondary care

Multiple sclerosis

3

2 d

2

Crosby et al. 2009

USA

Observational (Longitudinal)

Community

Eating disorders

6

2 w

3

Curran et al. 2004

USA

Observational (Longitudinal)

Secondary care

Cancer

4

5 d

3

Dekkers et al. 2000

Netherlands

Observational (Longitudinal)

Community

Rheumatoid arthritis

8 (PROMs)

9 (saliva)

2 d

2

de Wit et al. 1999

Netherlands

RCT

Secondary care

Cancer

2

2 m

6

Feuerecker et al. 2015

Germany

Observational (Longitudinal)

Secondary care

Chronic dizziness

5

1 d

3

Feys et al. 2012

USA, Spain, Belgium, Finland, Denmark

Observational (Longitudinal)

Secondary care

Multiple sclerosis

3

1 d

3

Graham-Engeland et al. 2016

USA

Observational (Longitudinal)

Community

Rheumatoid arthritis

5

7 d

2

Hamilton et al. 2007

USA

Observational (Longitudinal)

Secondary care

Fibromyalgia

7

2 d

2

Hardt et al. 1999

Germany

Observational (Cross-sectional)

Secondary care

Chronic pain

1

1 d

5

Houtveen et al. 2015

Netherlands

Observational (Longitudinal)

Community

Mental disorder

4

3 w

3

Kikuchi et al. 2012

Japan

Observational (Longitudinal)

Secondary care

Headache

4

7 d

3

Kleiman et al. 2017

USA

Observational (Longitudinal)

Community

Mood disorders

4

28 d

2

Kratz et al. 2016

USA

Observational (Longitudinal)

Community

Chronic pain

5

7 d

5

Lavender et al. 2013

USA

Observational (Longitudinal)

Secondary care

Eating Disorders

6

2 w

4

McCarley et al. 2007

USA

Observational (Longitudinal)

Community

Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disorder (COPD)

5

8 d

7

Okifuji et al. 2011

USA

Observational (Longitudinal)

Secondary care

Fibromyalgia

3

30 d

2

Partridge et al. 2009

Europe and USA

Observational (Cross-sectional)

Community

Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disorder (COPD)

1

1 day

2

Pfaltz et al. 2010

Switzerland

Observational (Longitudinal)

Community

Mood disorders

5

8 d

3

Powell et al. 2017

UK

Observational (Longitudinal)

Secondary care

Multiple sclerosis

6

4 d

7

Roche et al. 2013

France

Systematic Review

Various settings

Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disorder (COPD)

Varied

Varied

3

Schanberg et al. 2005

USA

Observational (Longitudinal)

Secondary care

Polyarthritic arthritis

1

2 m

6

Schlager et al. 1995

USA

Observational (Cross-sectional)

Primary care

Depression

1

1

5

Schwartz 2000

USA

Observational (Longitudinal)

Community

Cancer

1

8 w

4

Sewell et al. 2010

UK

RCT

Secondary care

Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disorder (COPD)

Twice (pre and post)

7 w (pre and post)

4

Shin and Lee 2014

Korea

Observational (Longitudinal)

Secondary care

Chronic pelvic pain

Every 2–3 months

27 m

3

Stinson 2008

Canada

Observational (Longitudinal)

Secondary care

Arthritis

3

2 w

2

Tsanas et al. 2016

UK

Observational (Longitudinal)

Secondary care and community

Depression

1

3 m

2

Vernon et al. 2010

USA

Observational (Longitudinal)

Primary care

Chronic cough

1

2 w

3

  1. aThe number of times measurements were completed in a day
  2. bd: days; w: weeks; m: months
  3. cA lower score on the CASP means article focused less on cyclical variation of PROMs (range from 0 to 7)
  4. dRandomised Controlled trial