Skip to main content

Table 2 PROMETHEUS concepts and domains with items

From: Development of a Patient Reported Measure of Experimental Transplants with HIV and Ethics in the United States (PROMETHEUS)

Concept

Domain

Sub-domains

Borrowed Scale

Preliminary Item

Final Item in PROMETHEUS v1.0

Consent Process

Satisfaction

With process

BICEP

7. Were you satisfied with the informed consent process?

C3. I was satisfied with the consent process to get the new organ.

With information given

Information Provided

Sufficiency

BICEP

1. Did you get all the information you needed to make a good decision about participating in [study]?

C1. I got all the information I needed to make a good decision about getting the new organ.

Complexity

Understood

Questions

Asked questions

All answered

Vulnerability

Illness

Time

Pressure

BICEP

3. Did you feel any pressure to participate in [study]?

C2. I felt pressure to accept the new organ.

Experimental Item

3. When I was told there was an organ available for me I felt pressure to accept it.

REMOVED

Decision Making

Reasons to Accept HIV D+ Organ

Already HIV+

Avoid/stop dialysis

Shorter wait time, healthier at time of transplant

More likely to get transplant

Experimental Item

5. Because of my race, joining this study was the best chance I had at getting a transplant.

D3. Because of my race, accepting this organ was the best chance I had at getting a transplant.

Experimental Item

6. Because of my HIV status, joining this study was the best chance I had at getting a transplant.

D4. Because of my HIV status, accepting this organ was the best chance I had at getting a transplant.

Contribution to science / research, help others

Discuss/Consult Study Participation With

Partner/Spouse

Family

Friends

Study doctor(s)

Experimental Item

2. Trust in the healthcare workers on the study team was a significant factor in my decision to participate.

D2. Trust in doctors and nurses who took care of me was a significant factor in my decision to get a new organ.

Other doctor(s)

Concerns

Transplant concerns

HIV concerns

Other concerns

Role

Passive

Collaborative

Active

Time to Decide

Immediate or almost immediate

Some time

Trust

In Medicine

A-WFPT Scale

1. Sometimes doctors care more about what is convenient for them than about their patients’ medical needs.

B1. Sometimes doctors care more about what is convenient for them than about their patients’ medical needs.

A-WFPT Scale

2. Doctors are extremely thorough and careful.

B2. Doctors are extremely thorough and careful.

A-WFPT Scale

3. You completely trust doctors’ decisions about which medical treatments are best.

B3. You completely trust doctors’ decisions about which medical treatments are best.

A-WFPT Scale

4. A doctor would never mislead you about anything.

B4. A doctor would never mislead you about anything.

A-WFPT Scale

5. All in all, you trust doctors completely.

B5. All in all, you trust doctors completely.

R-HCSD Scale

1. The Health Care System does its best to make patients’ health better.

B7. The Health Care System does its best to make patients’ health better.

In Medical Research

R-HCSD Scale

9. The Health Care System experiments on patients without them knowing.

B6. The health care system experiments on patients without them knowing.

Experimental Item

2. Trust in the healthcare workers on the study team was a significant factor in my decision to participate.

D2. Trust in doctors and nurses who took care of me was a significant factor in my decision to get a new organ.

In Institutions

MTHCS Scale

16. Health care institutions provide the highest quality in medical care.

REMOVED

Emotions

Decisional Regret

No regrets

Decision Regret Scale (DRS)

1. It was the right decision.

E1. It was the right decision.

DRS

3. I would go for the same choice if I had to do it over again.

E3. I would make the same decision if I had to do it again.

DRS

5. The decision was a wise one.

E5. The decision was a wise one.

Initial regrets

Lingering regrets

DRS

2. I regret the choice that was made.

E2. I regret the decision that was made.

DRS

4. The choice did me a lot of harm.

E4. The decision did me a lot of harm.

Feeling Unprepared for Transplant

At time of tx

Time b/w consent & tx very short

Not ready for tx when first offered

For recovery

Immunosuppression

Experimental Item

1. My recovery was harder than I imagined.

D1. My recovery was harder than I imagined.

Follow-up visits

Generally worse than imagined

Grateful/Lucky

Thanks to donor/donor family

Thanks to medical team

Thanks to research

Thanks to “God”/religion

Fear

PROMIS Anxiety SF 8a

1. I felt fearful …

A1. I felt fearful …

Fairness

Self

Others

Impact of Transplant

Physical Function

More active, life back to normal

Less active, healthier at/before transplant

Social Function

Relationships w/partner, family, friends

PROMIS Anxiety SF 8a

2. I found it hard to focus on anything other than my anxiety …

A2. I found it hard to focus on anything other than my anxiety …

Ability to work

Ability to travel

Overall Health

Mental Health/ Cognitive Abilities

PROMIS Anxiety SF 8a

1. I felt fearful …

A1. I felt fearful …

PROMIS Anxiety SF 8a

2. I found it hard to focus on anything other than my anxiety …

A2. I found it hard to focus on anything other than my anxiety …

PROMIS Anxiety SF 8a

3. My worries overwhelmed me …

A3. My worries overwhelmed me …

PROMIS Anxiety SF 8a

4. I felt uneasy …

A4. I felt uneasy …

PROMIS Anxiety SF 8a

5. I felt nervous …

A5. I felt nervous …

PROMIS Anxiety SF 8a

6. I felt like I needed help for my anxiety …

A6. I felt like I needed help for my anxiety …

PROMIS Anxiety SF 8a

7. I felt anxious …

A7. I felt anxious …

PROMIS Anxiety SF 8a

8. I felt tense …

A8. I felt tense …

Stigma

HIV Status

Experimental Item

6. Because of my HIV status, joining this study was the best chance I had at getting a transplant.

D4. Because of my HIV status, accepting this organ was the best chance I had at getting a transplant.

Experimental Item

7. Being a part of this study made me feel better about having HIV.

D5. Being able to get this transplant made me feel better about having HIV.

Experimental Item

8. This study makes me feel like my HIV diagnosis gives me the unique ability to help others.

REMOVED

Addiction / Substance Abuse

Race/Ethnicity

R-HCSD Scale

7. Patients get the same medical treatment from the Health Care System, no matter what the patient’s race or ethnicity.

B8. Patients get the same medical treatment from the health care system, no matter what the patient’s race or ethnicity.

Experimental Item

5. Because of my race, joining this study was the best chance I had at getting a transplant.

D3. Because of my race, accepting this organ was the best chance I had at getting a transplant.

Poverty

Sexuality

Gender Identity

Transplant/Illness

Support

From Partner/Spouse

From Family

From Friends

From Medical Team

Experimental Item

2. Trust in the healthcare workers on the study team was a significant factor in my decision to participate.

D2. Trust in doctors and nurses who took care of me was a significant factor in my decision to get a new organ.

From Research Team

Experimental Item

2. Trust in the healthcare workers on the study team was a significant factor in my decision to participate.

D2. Trust in doctors and nurses who took care of me was a significant factor in my decision to get a new organ.

HIV Status of Donor

False-Positive or HIV- Donor is Better

Experimental Item

4. I was relieved to learn that I got an HIV negative organ and not one that was HIV positive.

REMOVED

Does Not Matter

 

Who Knows About Study Participation

Want to Tell/Has Told People

Does Not Want to Tell

HIV status not public

Don’t want others reactions/ opinions (negative or positive)

Privacy

Worried about stigma