Concept | Domain | Sub-domains | Borrowed Scale | Preliminary Item | Final Item in PROMETHEUS v1.0 | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Consent Process | Satisfaction | With process | BICEP | 7. Were you satisfied with the informed consent process? | C3. I was satisfied with the consent process to get the new organ. | |
With information given | ||||||
Information Provided | Sufficiency | BICEP | 1. Did you get all the information you needed to make a good decision about participating in [study]? | C1. I got all the information I needed to make a good decision about getting the new organ. | ||
Complexity | ||||||
Understood | ||||||
Questions | Asked questions | – | – | – | ||
All answered | ||||||
Vulnerability | Illness | – | – | – | ||
Time | – | – | – | |||
Pressure | BICEP | 3. Did you feel any pressure to participate in [study]? | C2. I felt pressure to accept the new organ. | |||
Experimental Item | 3. When I was told there was an organ available for me I felt pressure to accept it. | REMOVED | ||||
Decision Making | Reasons to Accept HIV D+ Organ | Already HIV+ | – | – | – | |
Avoid/stop dialysis | – | – | – | |||
Shorter wait time, healthier at time of transplant | – | – | – | |||
More likely to get transplant | Experimental Item | 5. Because of my race, joining this study was the best chance I had at getting a transplant. | D3. Because of my race, accepting this organ was the best chance I had at getting a transplant. | |||
Experimental Item | 6. Because of my HIV status, joining this study was the best chance I had at getting a transplant. | D4. Because of my HIV status, accepting this organ was the best chance I had at getting a transplant. | ||||
Contribution to science / research, help others | – | – | – | |||
Discuss/Consult Study Participation With | Partner/Spouse | – | – | – | ||
Family | – | – | – | |||
Friends | – | – | – | |||
Study doctor(s) | Experimental Item | 2. Trust in the healthcare workers on the study team was a significant factor in my decision to participate. | D2. Trust in doctors and nurses who took care of me was a significant factor in my decision to get a new organ. | |||
Other doctor(s) | – | – | – | |||
Concerns | Transplant concerns | – | – | – | ||
HIV concerns | ||||||
Other concerns | ||||||
Role | Passive | – | – | – | ||
Collaborative | ||||||
Active | ||||||
Time to Decide | Immediate or almost immediate | – | – | – | ||
Some time | ||||||
Trust | In Medicine | – | A-WFPT Scale | 1. Sometimes doctors care more about what is convenient for them than about their patients’ medical needs. | B1. Sometimes doctors care more about what is convenient for them than about their patients’ medical needs. | |
A-WFPT Scale | 2. Doctors are extremely thorough and careful. | B2. Doctors are extremely thorough and careful. | ||||
A-WFPT Scale | 3. You completely trust doctors’ decisions about which medical treatments are best. | B3. You completely trust doctors’ decisions about which medical treatments are best. | ||||
A-WFPT Scale | 4. A doctor would never mislead you about anything. | B4. A doctor would never mislead you about anything. | ||||
A-WFPT Scale | 5. All in all, you trust doctors completely. | B5. All in all, you trust doctors completely. | ||||
R-HCSD Scale | 1. The Health Care System does its best to make patients’ health better. | B7. The Health Care System does its best to make patients’ health better. | ||||
In Medical Research | – | R-HCSD Scale | 9. The Health Care System experiments on patients without them knowing. | B6. The health care system experiments on patients without them knowing. | ||
Experimental Item | 2. Trust in the healthcare workers on the study team was a significant factor in my decision to participate. | D2. Trust in doctors and nurses who took care of me was a significant factor in my decision to get a new organ. | ||||
In Institutions | – | MTHCS Scale | 16. Health care institutions provide the highest quality in medical care. | REMOVED | ||
Emotions | Decisional Regret | No regrets | Decision Regret Scale (DRS) | 1. It was the right decision. | E1. It was the right decision. | |
DRS | 3. I would go for the same choice if I had to do it over again. | E3. I would make the same decision if I had to do it again. | ||||
DRS | 5. The decision was a wise one. | E5. The decision was a wise one. | ||||
Initial regrets | – | – | – | |||
Lingering regrets | DRS | 2. I regret the choice that was made. | E2. I regret the decision that was made. | |||
DRS | 4. The choice did me a lot of harm. | E4. The decision did me a lot of harm. | ||||
Feeling Unprepared for Transplant | At time of tx | Time b/w consent & tx very short | – | – | – | |
Not ready for tx when first offered | – | – | – | |||
For recovery | Immunosuppression | Experimental Item | 1. My recovery was harder than I imagined. | D1. My recovery was harder than I imagined. | ||
Follow-up visits | ||||||
Generally worse than imagined | ||||||
Grateful/Lucky | Thanks to donor/donor family | – | – | – | ||
Thanks to medical team | ||||||
Thanks to research | ||||||
Thanks to “God”/religion | ||||||
Fear | – | PROMIS Anxiety SF 8a | 1. I felt fearful … | A1. I felt fearful … | ||
Fairness | Self | – | – | – | ||
Others | ||||||
Impact of Transplant | Physical Function | More active, life back to normal | – | – | – | |
Less active, healthier at/before transplant | ||||||
Social Function | Relationships w/partner, family, friends | PROMIS Anxiety SF 8a | 2. I found it hard to focus on anything other than my anxiety … | A2. I found it hard to focus on anything other than my anxiety … | ||
Ability to work | ||||||
Ability to travel | ||||||
Overall Health | – | – | – | – | ||
Mental Health/ Cognitive Abilities | – | PROMIS Anxiety SF 8a | 1. I felt fearful … | A1. I felt fearful … | ||
PROMIS Anxiety SF 8a | 2. I found it hard to focus on anything other than my anxiety … | A2. I found it hard to focus on anything other than my anxiety … | ||||
PROMIS Anxiety SF 8a | 3. My worries overwhelmed me … | A3. My worries overwhelmed me … | ||||
PROMIS Anxiety SF 8a | 4. I felt uneasy … | A4. I felt uneasy … | ||||
PROMIS Anxiety SF 8a | 5. I felt nervous … | A5. I felt nervous … | ||||
PROMIS Anxiety SF 8a | 6. I felt like I needed help for my anxiety … | A6. I felt like I needed help for my anxiety … | ||||
PROMIS Anxiety SF 8a | 7. I felt anxious … | A7. I felt anxious … | ||||
PROMIS Anxiety SF 8a | 8. I felt tense … | A8. I felt tense … | ||||
Stigma | HIV Status | – | Experimental Item | 6. Because of my HIV status, joining this study was the best chance I had at getting a transplant. | D4. Because of my HIV status, accepting this organ was the best chance I had at getting a transplant. | |
Experimental Item | 7. Being a part of this study made me feel better about having HIV. | D5. Being able to get this transplant made me feel better about having HIV. | ||||
Experimental Item | 8. This study makes me feel like my HIV diagnosis gives me the unique ability to help others. | REMOVED | ||||
Addiction / Substance Abuse | – | – | – | – | ||
Race/Ethnicity | – | R-HCSD Scale | 7. Patients get the same medical treatment from the Health Care System, no matter what the patient’s race or ethnicity. | B8. Patients get the same medical treatment from the health care system, no matter what the patient’s race or ethnicity. | ||
Experimental Item | 5. Because of my race, joining this study was the best chance I had at getting a transplant. | D3. Because of my race, accepting this organ was the best chance I had at getting a transplant. | ||||
Poverty | – | – | – | – | ||
Sexuality | – | – | – | – | ||
Gender Identity | – | – | – | – | ||
Transplant/Illness | – | – | – | – | ||
Support | From Partner/Spouse | – | – | – | – | |
From Family | – | – | – | – | ||
From Friends | – | – | – | – | ||
From Medical Team | – | Experimental Item | 2. Trust in the healthcare workers on the study team was a significant factor in my decision to participate. | D2. Trust in doctors and nurses who took care of me was a significant factor in my decision to get a new organ. | ||
From Research Team | – | Experimental Item | 2. Trust in the healthcare workers on the study team was a significant factor in my decision to participate. | D2. Trust in doctors and nurses who took care of me was a significant factor in my decision to get a new organ. | ||
HIV Status of Donor | False-Positive or HIV- Donor is Better | – | Experimental Item | 4. I was relieved to learn that I got an HIV negative organ and not one that was HIV positive. | REMOVED | |
Does Not Matter | – | – | – | |||
Who Knows About Study Participation | Want to Tell/Has Told People | – | – | – | – | |
Does Not Want to Tell | HIV status not public | – | – | – | ||
Don’t want others reactions/ opinions (negative or positive) | – | – | – | |||
Privacy | – | – | – | |||
Worried about stigma | – | – | – |